Pre-Qualified or Pre-Approved? In This Market That One Word Decides Who Gets the House
Pre-Qualified or Pre-Approved? In This Market That One Word Decides Who Gets the House
The Saturday Marcus and Trina lost a house they had already decorated in their heads
Brick colonial in Bowie. Cul de sac. A back yard their daughter walked into and refused to leave.
By the time they got back to the car Trina had picked out the room she wanted for her mother.
They wrote the offer that afternoon. Full price. Their lender told them on the phone two weeks before that they'd have no trouble, and sent a letter saying so.
They lost to an offer four thousand dollars under theirs.
When Marcus called me the first thing he asked was what he did wrong. He didn't do anything wrong, exactly. He did what buyers were told to do for twenty years. Find the house, then go get the money.
That order used to work fine. Today it's about the worst way to go about it.
His letter said pre-qualified. The winning letter said pre-approved. That was it. That was the whole thing..
What a phone call gets you
In my experinece, a lender will pre-qualify you in ten minutes. They ask what you make, what you owe, what you've saved, how your credit's been. You answer. They do the math and tell you roughly what you can borrow.
None of it is verified. It's an estimate built on what you told them, and it's only as good as your memory of your own finances at nine on a Tuesday morning.
I'm not knocking it. Pre-qualification is useful early. It tells you whether you're shopping at four hundred thousand or six fifty before you burn three weekends on the wrong houses. As a first step it does its job.
It just doesn't win anything.
What a pre-approval is
You applied. Filled out the mortgage application. They pulled your credit report themselves instead of asking what your score was. Called your employer. Went through your bank statements, your tax returns, your assets.
An underwriter looked at your real numbers and said yes, up to a specific figure.
That figure isn't an estimate. It's a decision.
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau lays the difference out plainly if you want it from a neutral source: What is a mortgage pre-approval?
The offer that beat them
Six weeks after Bowie, Marcus and Trina were pre-approved. Not pre-qualified. Approved, with a letter from a credit union in Largo that had already checked everything.
Next house was in Mitchellville. Smaller. Better street, if I'm being honest about it. They were one of five offers and they were not the highest.
They got it.
I know why because the listing agent told me after. Her sellers had already lost one contract at financing and they weren't doing that again. When she put the five offers on the kitchen table she laid theirs on top and said, this one is real money.
That's the part buyers miss. A seller isn't picking a number. They're picking a number and the odds it survives to closing. Your pre-approval is you handing them proof the odds are good.
Why sellers read the letter before the price
Every listing agent in Prince George's County has a story about a deal that fell apart three weeks in because somebody's financing was never as solid as the letter made it sound. House comes back on the market with days on market stacked against it. Sellers already gave notice on their rental, or went under contract somewhere else.
So they read the letter first now.
Pre-qualified says this person thinks they can afford it. Pre-approved says a lender checked and they can. With four other offers on the table that stops being paperwork and starts being the reason you're moving in September.
Denise, and the lender who cost her Silver Spring
Getting pre-approved matters. Getting pre-approved with somebody competent matters just as much, and nobody warns you about that part.
Denise had her letter in hand when we found the place in Silver Spring. Ratified contract, appraisal ordered, everything moving.
Then her file went quiet.
Her lender lost a pay stub he'd already been sent. Asked twice for a document she emailed in March. Couldn't tell her what her rate was locked at, then told her something different two days later. Every question I asked came back late and came back vague.
Eleven days out from closing, no clear to close, no explanation. Sellers extended once. They wouldn't extend twice.
Denise didn't lose that house because she couldn't afford it. She could. She lost it because the man handling her money couldn't keep track of a file.
She bought in Hyattsville four months later with somebody else. That one closed early.
What counts as a legitimate lender
You've got real choices and all of these are fine:
Banks. Mortgage bankers. Credit unions. Savings and loan associations. Mortgage brokers. Online lenders.
The category matters less than the person. I've watched enormous national banks fumble simple files and small local brokers close in nineteen days.
One thing worth doing before you hand anybody your social security number: look them up. Mortgage loan originators are licensed and searchable at NMLS Consumer Access, which is free and takes about a minute.
The warning signs, in the order you'll notice them
They lose things. A form goes missing. A file gets misplaced. You send the same document twice. This shows up first and it's the one people excuse, because early on it feels small. It isn't small. It's a preview.
They ask for things at random. A good lender gives you one list up front. A weak one comes back every three days with something new they suddenly need, which tells you nobody read your file properly the first time.
They can't tell you your rate, your points, or your costs. Not "rates move daily," which is true. I mean they can't tell you what yours is, today, as a number. That isn't market volatility. That's not knowing.
Once you're under contract you'll get a Loan Estimate, and it's a standardized form for a reason. Every lender's looks the same so you can hold two side by side and compare them honestly. The CFPB walks through how to read one here: Understanding the Loan Estimate
They can't give you a straight answer. Ask what happens if the appraisal comes in low. Ask what your cash to close will be. If the answer is a paragraph that goes around the question, you learned something useful while it's still cheap to learn it.
My opinion, after sixteen years of watching this
Buyers who start without a solid plan and a professional they trust do not have a smooth experience. I've never seen it go the other way.
It isn't about being smart or having money. Marcus and Trina had both. Denise had both. What they didn't have on the first try was somebody in the seat who knew the road, and the market punished them for it in the only currency it deals in, which is time and houses they didn't get.
The people who move through this cleanly aren't lucky. They got their financing settled before they fell in love with anything, and they picked people who answer the phone.
The order that works now
Find the lender. Get fully pre-approved. Then go look.
Feels backward if you bought a house in 2012. It isn't. It means that by the time you walk into the one with the back yard your daughter won't leave, you already know what you can do about it. So does the seller.
Marcus said it better than I can, standing in that Mitchellville kitchen the day they closed.
"We didn't lose the first house because somebody outbid us. We lost it because we weren't ready and they were."
Before you start looking
Planning a move in Prince George's County, Montgomery County, Washington, DC or Northern Virginia? Look at the top of the letter you're holding. It'll say pre-qualified or pre-approved. That one word was worth four thousand dollars to Marcus and Trina.
If you want an introduction to a lender who returns calls and keeps a file straight, that's a short conversation. My list is short on purpose.
Travell Eiland is a Broker Associate, The Concierge Agent, and founder of The Concierge Agency, a real estate authority in the DMV. More than 16 years working at top brokerages including Keller Williams Preferred Properties in Upper Marlboro, MD and Samson Properties in Bowie, MD and Chantilly, VA. The Concierge Agency serves Prince George's County, Montgomery County, Washington, DC and Northern Virginia.
Client names and details have been changed.
SOURCES:
Categories
Recent Posts
